问题 问答题 案例分析题

阅读下列材料,回答问题。

有人说;“妥协是政治的灵魂。”许多国家的民主进程中都体现了妥协的存在。阅读材料,完成下列问题。

材料一:阿克顿说,“妥协是政治的灵魂,如果不是其全部的话”。达尔也说:“民主依赖妥协”。

材料二:法国之所以要用暴力革命来克服专制王权,原因就在于法国专制主义过于强大,王权与贵族坚决捍卫旧制度,不愿做出任何妥协,对立双方只好兵戎相见。然而,大革命并没有解决根本问题,此后近百年中,法国一直处于革命与复辟的轮回中,社会持续动荡,经济发展速度受到影响,工业化进程缓慢。直到1870年后,法国模式突然发生转折,由对抗转为妥协。此后没再发生大规模的革命,法国人开始用协商手段逐步建立起民主制度。

——钱乘旦《各国现代化模式的比较》

材料三:美国宪法是美国建国初期多元利益集团谈判和妥协的结果;宪法所创立的也是一个利益谈判和妥协的政治机制;在美国两百多年的历史上,不同的利益集团(群体)因应不断变化的历史环境,利用依宪法衍生的宪政机制,就各自的利益和联邦的“公共”利益的定义和定位,相互进行一种连续不停的谈判和妥协;谈判和妥协使旧的宪法原则和实践得以修正,使新的宪法原则和实践得以产生,宪法的生命力不断得到更新,表现出一种“超稳定性”,成为一部“活着的宪法”。

——王希《原则与妥协》

材料四:传统的主流历史叙事否认这场“大妥协“具有任何积极意义,认为它恰恰体现了革命的不彻底性:大批旧官僚和立宪派“投机”革命,“篡夺”了革命果实;“大妥协”中优待清朝逊帝的做法,也为民国时的君主复辟埋下了伏笔。但近年以来,已有一些研究论文试图对这场“大妥协”作出不同的评价。如喻大华的《新论——兼探溥仪潜往东北的一个原因》指出,对袁世凯的妥协是孙中山的战略和策略。一个维系了二千多年的封建君主专制,要废于一旦,必须具备多种条件,绝非单凭武力能够解决,《清室优待条件》并非由袁世凯一方炮制,而是由南方首先提出,南北双方经过协商达成一致意见。

——章永乐《论清王朝与中华民国的“大妥协”》

依据材料三理解美国的宪法为什么能成为一部“活着”的宪法?结合所学知识回答,美国宪法制定中“多元利益的妥协”表现在哪些方面?

答案

参考答案:

原因:宪法创立的是一个利益谈判和妥协的政治机制;不同的利益集团因不断变化的历史环境谈判妥协修正。表现:中央集权和地方自治之间;大州和小州之间;南方和北方之间;参议院和众议院之间;国会、总统和联邦法院之间;

解析:

结合所学知识,根据1787年宪法,可知,之所以美国的宪法能成为一部“活着”的宪法,是由于这部宪法在不断发展,做到了实事求是,兼顾了多方利益。结合所学知识,美国宪法制定中“多元利益的妥协”体现在:第一,中央集权和地方自治之间;第二,大州和小州之间;第三,南方和北方之间;第四,参议院和众议院之间;第五,国会、总统和联邦法院之间等。

阅读理解

Over the past century, all kinds of unfairness and discrimination have been made illegal. But one popular form continues to exist, that is alphabetism (字母排序法). This, for those as yet unaware of such a disadvantage, refers to discrimination against those whose surnames(姓氏)begin with a letter in the lower half of the alphabet.

It has long been known that the cars of a taxi firm called AAAA have a big advantage over Zodiac cars when customers look through their phone directories. Less well known is the advantage that Adam Abbot has in life over Zoe Zysman. English names are fairly spread between the halves of the alphabet. Yet a quite large number of top people have surnames beginning with letters between A and K.

Thus the American presidents and vice-presidents have surnames starting with B and  C separately and 26 of those before George Bush took office (including his father ) had surnames in the first half of the alphabet against just 16 in the second half. Even more striking, six of the seven heads of government of the G7 rich countries are alphabetically advantaged (Berlusconi, Blair, Bush, Chirac, Chretien and Koizumi). The world's three top central bankers ( Greenspan, Duisenberg and Hayami)are all close to the top of the alphabet, even if one of them really uses Japanese characters. The same case are the world's five richest men ( Gates, Buffet and so on) .

Can this merely happen by chance? At the start of the first year in primary school, teachers seat pupils, alphabetically from the front, to make it easier to remember their names. So shortsighted and small-sized Zysman junior gets stuck in the back row, and is seldom asked the improving questions by those teachers. At that time the alphabetically disadvantaged may think they have had a lucky escape. Yet the result may be worse qualifications, because they get less attention, as well as less confidence in speaking publicly.

The unfairness continues. At university graduation parties, the ABCs proudly get their awards first. However, by the time they reach the Zysmans most people are a little tired. Lists of job interviews and conference speakers and attendees all tend to be drawn up alphabetically, and their readers lose interest as they plough through them.

小题1:What does the author intend to show with AAAA cars and Zodiac cars?

A.An example of competition of two kinds of cars.

B.Some advantages of AAAA cars in the taxi firm.

C.An example of unfairness caused by alphabetism.

D.Some disadvantages of Zodiac cars in the taxi firm.小题2:What can we infer from the first three paragraphs?

A.The alphabet is to blame for the failure of Zoe Zysman.

B.In both East and West, names are important to success.

C.Customers often pay a lot of attention to companies' names.

D.The discrimination in alphabetism can be found in many areas.小题3:The fourth paragraph suggests that         .

A.alphabetically disadvantaged often escape from class

B.teachers should pay equal attention to all their students

C.questions are often put to the more intelligent students

D.students should be seated according to their eyesight小题4:Which of the following is TRUE according to the passage?

A.VIPs in the western world gain a great deal from alphabetism.

B.People with surnames beginning with N to Z are often misunderstood.

C.Putting things alphabetically may lead to unintentional unfairness.

D.The movement to get rid of alphabetism still has a long way to go.

填空题