问题 问答题 简答题

2007年11月,A公司向B银行借款2000万元,期限2年。A公司将其所属一栋房屋作为抵押并办理了抵押权登记。

2008年1月,A公司与C公司签订书面合同,将该房屋出租给C公司,租期5年,月租金5万元,每年1月底前一次付清全年租金。2009年1月,经A公司同意,C公司与D公司订立书面合同,将该房屋转租给D公司,租期4年,月租金8万元。根据约定,D公司的租金缴付方式为:每年1月底前向C公司缴付3万元,向A公司缴付5万元。但合同签订后,D公司除向C公司缴付了3万元租金外,一直未向A公司缴付,C公司也未向A公司缴付2009年租金。

后A公司无力清偿对B银行的借款。经B银行同意,A公司于2009年年底与E公司签订买卖合同,以2000万元的市场价格将房屋售与E公司,并约定2010年1月初办理过户登记。

2010年1月1日,D公司因违反约定使用房屋引发火灾,造成房屋损失100万元。C公司为此解除了与D公司的转租合同并收回房屋。1月5日,C公司对因火灾造成的房屋损失向A公司赔偿100万元。A公司与E公司于2010年1月6日依约办理了房屋过户手续。E公司要求C公司腾退房屋,C公司以“买卖不破租赁”为由予以拒绝。次日,C公司进而向A公司主张,A公司未告知其房屋出售之事,侵害了自己的优先购买权,A公司和E公司之间的买卖合同因此无效,E公司并未取得房屋所有权。

E公司发现房屋受损,经与A公司协商,E公司在应支付房屋价款中扣除100万元,只向A公司支付了1900万元。A公司将此1900万元支付给B银行,B银行则认为,其对于A公司因房屋受损而获得的100万元赔偿款也享有优先受偿权。此外,A公司和E公司均认为,欠缴的2009年全年租金应由自己收取。

要求:

根据上述内容,分别回答下列问题:

C公司关于A公司和E公司之间的房屋买卖合同无效的主张是否成立?并说明理由。

答案

参考答案:

C公司的主张不成立。根据规定,出租人出卖租赁房屋未在合理期限内通知承租人或者存在其他侵害承租人优先购买权的情形,承租人请求出租人承担赔偿责任的,人民法院应予支持;但请求确认出租人与第三人签订的房屋买卖合同无效的,人民法院不予支持。在本题中,C公司关于A公司和E公司之间的房屋买卖合同无效的主张不成立。

【或者】根据规定,出租人侵害承租人的优先购买权的,承租人不得主张出租人与第三人订立的房屋买卖合同无效,只能请求出租人承担赔偿责任。

单项选择题

This was one of my experiences (1) . When I was in my 30s, I was working for a large international company which had its head office in London. I was working in the (2) department.

The company had a training centre which was just outside London. Different courses were held there throughout (3) and I (4) go on one training course a year. These usually started (5) a Sunday evening and lasted six days.

Once I was (6) a week’s training course with about forty (7) sales people. I was in the bar on the Friday evening and suddenly a woman who was (8) behind the bar asked mea curious question. "I hope you don’t (9) my asking," she said, "but I’ve been (10) about it all week. Have you got a sister (11) Mary" The woman’s name was June. And she used to do various jobs at the training centre. She worked in the office, she organized all the food and drink for the centre and she worked in the bar at lunchtime and in the evening.

My answer (12) June’s question was "Yes", and June said, "I thought (13) . I met her last September when she was organizing a course here. " At that time, my sister was working for (14) company but in a different part of the country. That was (15) she came to be at the training centre.

(16) surprised me was how June guessed we were brother and sister. Three things made it even more (17) . First, she had met my sister six months before she met me. Second, they have about sixty new people every week at the training centre. So about one thousand five hundred people had (18) the centre in those six months. And (19) , my sister is married, so she doesn’t have the same family name as me.

We’re not (20) , but I guess we must look quite like each other.

4().

A.used to

B.once

C.get used to

D.was used to

名词解释