问题 单项选择题

研究发现,市面上X牌香烟的Y成分可以抑制EB病毒。实验证实,EB病毒是很强的致鼻咽癌的病原体,可以导致正常的鼻咽部细胞转化为癌细胞。因此,经常吸X牌香烟的人将减少患鼻咽癌的风险。
以下哪项如果为真,最能削弱上述论证( )

A.不同条件下的实验可以得出类似的结论。

B.已经患有鼻咽癌的患者吸X牌香烟后并未发现病情好转。

C.Y成分可以抑制EB病毒,也可以对人的免疫系统产生负面作用。

D.Y成分的作用可以被X牌香烟的Z成分中和。

答案

参考答案:D

解析: 如果D选项下确,大家肯定认为题干的论述具有欺骗性,即没有把Y成分的作用可以被x牌香烟的Z成分中和的这一实际情况说明,误导了消费者。如果Y成分的作用可以被X牌香烟的Z成分中和的话,那么Y成分就不能抑制EB病毒了。这样就削弱了题干的论证。答案为D。

单项选择题

Sustainable development is applied to just about everything from energy to clean water and economic growth, and as a result it has become difficult to question either the basic assumptions behind it or the way the concept is put to use. This is especially true in agriculture, where sustainable development is often taken as the sole measure of progress without a proper appreciation of historical and cultural perspectives.

To start with, it is important to remember that the nature of agriculture has changed markedly throughout history, and will continue to do so. Medieval agriculture in northern Europe fed, clothed and sheltered a predominantly rural society with a much lower population density than it is today. It had minimal effect on biodiversity, and any pollution it caused was typically localized. In terms of energy use and the nutrients captured in the product it was relatively inefficient.

Contrast this with farming since the start of the industrial revolution. Competition from overseas led farmers to specialize and increase yields. Throughout this period food became cheaper, safer and more reliable. However, these changes have also led to habitat loss.

What’s more, demand for animal products in developing countries is growing so fast that meeting it will require an extra 300 million tons of grain a year by 2050. Yet the growth of cities and industry is reducing the amount of water available for agriculture in many regions.

All this means that agriculture in the 21st century will have to be very different from how it was in the 20th. This will require radical thinking. For example, we need to move away from the idea that traditional practices are inevitably more sustainable than new ones. We also need to abandon the notion that agriculture can be "zero impact". The key will be to abandon the rather simple and static measures of sustainability, which centre on the need to maintain production without increasing damage. Instead we need a more dynamic interpretation, one that looks at the pros and cons of all the various ways land is used. There are many different agricultural performances besides food yield: energy use, environmental costs, water purity, carbon footprint and biodiversity. It is clear, for example, that the carbon of transporting tomatoes from Spain to the UK is less than that of producing them in the UK with additional heating and lighting. But we do not know whether lower carbon footprints will always be better for biodiversity. What is crucial is recognizing that sustainable agriculture is not just about sustainable food production.

How do people often measure progress in agriculture()

A.By its productivity.

B.By its sustainability.

C.By its impact on the environment.

D.By its contribution to economic growt

单项选择题 A1/A2型题