问题 问答题 案例分析题

2008年8月16日下午5时左右,某村刮起了8级大风。该村村民王某路经村委会在建的办公楼时,大风将建楼所用的脚手架刮倒。脚手架在倒塌过程中将一根电线砸断,电线正巧落在由此路过的王某身上,王某不幸触电身亡。王某的家人向法院起诉,要求村委会和供电公司对王某的死亡承担损害赔偿责任。村委会辩称:脚手架是大风刮倒的,击中王某的输电线路属于供电公司,村委会对王某的死亡不应承担损害赔偿责任。供电公司辩称:供电线路是被脚手架砸断的,脚手架是村委会盖办公楼时使用的,供电公司对王某的死亡不应承担损害赔偿责任。法院审理还查明,村委会用于建办公楼的脚手架在当年7月2日搭建完毕。击中王某的输电线路归供电公司所有,该线路不属于高压线。

根据上述案情,请回答:

两被告主张的抗辩事由是否成立?请说明理由。

答案

参考答案:

两被告主张的抗辩事由不能成立。

对村委会而言,大风尚不能构成不可抗力。村委会应当预见到脚手架在外力(包括大风)的作用下可能倒塌并造成损害后果的危险,并应及时消除危险;对供电公司而言,脚手架倒塌不能构成抗辩事由。

供电公司应注意到供电设施周围的物体、设施在外力作用下,对输电线路安全的影响,并应对安全隐患及时处理。

完形填空

寒假中,Wang Wei, Jiang Jian, Hu Peng , Ma Lili, Shao Bing五人分别参与了不同的社会服务工作。阅读下列材料,从A、B、C、D、E中找出与五个人相关联的活动项目。

A、Children’s Hospital  

B、The Old People’s Home  

C、City Clean-up

D、The Left-behind Cildren’s Home   

E、Planting trees

Wang Wei: It was a sunny but a little cold morning. I with many people went to hills outside the city.We dug the holes, planted the small trees and watered them well.I hope we can make our environment greener and more beautiful.

Jiang Jian, One Sunday, I went to visit the kids who were not well in hospital. I stayed with them all the morning,playing games,taking walks,or even helping them with homework.While I was with them,time went quickly.

Hu Peng , It was a meaningful and educational trip for me.We family went to a village in the mountains.There we stayed with five children whose parents couldn’t come back home for the festival with them. During the three days,we did many interesting and helpful things.  .

Ma Lili,  One of the most important and meaningful things for me in the winter holiday is to join Cleaning Our City.We cleaned the street,picked up the rubbish and called on more people to help out with our city.

Shao Bing: During the last week, I with my classmates went to see the old people. We bought some fruit ,flowers and something else. We cleaned the house,talked with the old people. Some of us sang and danced ,some read newspapers to them. I am sure it was the most enjoyable time for the old people,and for us,too.

Wang Wei__小题1:__, Jiang Jian_小题2:__, Hu Peng __小题3:__,Ma Lili___小题4:__ Shao Bing _小题5:_

连线题