问题 问答题

案情:甲有限责任公司注册资本20万元,有股东5人,王某、李某、张某和陈某是自然人股东,各持有公司2万元的股份,乙企业是法人股东,持有公司12万元的股份。王某欲将股份转让给丙企业,王某书面通知李某、张某、陈某和乙企业,李某不同意王某将股份转让给丙企业,张某、陈某同意王某转让,乙企业收到王某的书面通知后迟迟不作出答复,直至两个月后通知王某不同意转让。王某、张某、陈某均认为王某有权转让,张某、陈某都主张优先购买权,但是购买的比例协商不成。
张某和陈某提出的购买条件低于丙企业,乙企业拒绝购买王某的股份,王某遂将股份转让给丙企业。李某坚决反对王某将股份转让给丙企业,王某将股份转让给丙企业后,李某要求公司购买自己的股份,公司拒绝购买,李某向法院提起诉讼要求公司购买自己的股份,法院判决李某败诉。张某决定出国定居,在未经其他股东同意的情况下将自己的股份转让给丙企业。公司后来经股东会决议将注册资本降低至8万元,并且办理了变更登记。由于公司经营困难,李某、陈某和乙企业均将股份转让给丙企业。
问题:

法院判决李某败诉是否符合法律规定为什么

答案

参考答案:[答案及解析] 法院判决李某败诉符合法律规定。必须发生法定情形,股东方有权要求公司收购自己持有的公司股份。根据《公司法》的相关规定,股东向股东之外的人转让股权,反对转让的股东无权要求公司收购自己的股份。《公司法》第75条规定:“有下列情形之一的,对股东会该项决议投反对票的股东可以请求公司按照合理的价格收购其股权:(一)公司连续五年不向股东分配利润,而公司该五年连续盈利,并且符合本法规定的分配利润条件的;(二)公司合并、分立、转让主要财产的;(三)公司章程规定的营业期限届满或者章程规定的其他解散事由出现,股东会会议通过决议修改章程使公司存续的。自股东会会议决议通过之日起六十日内,股东与公司不能达成股权收购协议的,股东可以自股东会会议决议通过之日起九十日内向人民法院提起诉讼。”该条规定了股东有权请求公司收购其股份的法定情形,只要不符合这些情形,股东无权请求公司收购自己的股份,本题中反对股东向公司股东之外的人转让股份的情形不符合公司收购股东股份的法定情形,所以法院判决李某败诉符合法律规定。

多项选择题
阅读理解

I. Associate Product Manager -- New Grad-- Beijing

Responsibilities include working with engineers to define products, understanding user needs, researching markets and competitors, and planning future product directions. As you gain more experience, there’s an opportunity for promotion within the organization.

Requirements:

☆Bachelors degree and more than one year of job experience.

☆Strong organizational and analytical skills.

II. Director of Education -- Sylvan Learning Centers -- Long Beach, California

Job description:

As a successful director of education, your primary responsibility will be to champion the Sylvan developed course, ensure the quality of the education standards and teachings staff as well as grow the business in your center.

We require:

☆Bachelors degree and at least 2 years of teaching experience.

☆Managerial experience.

III. Area Export Manager -- Beijing Import&Export Corporation -- Beijing

Highly developing company is looking for bright, experienced salesperson who will be responsible for the export of frozen seafood and other goods between China and the USA, Australia, and Canada.

Qualifications:

☆Excellent level of English,spoken and written.

☆Excellent communication and organizational skills.

☆Experienced salesperson with proven results in fast-moving consumer goods essential,preferable in frozen seafood market.

IV. Subeditor---Media Contacts----London

Working in the amazing world of law and enforcement(执法), you will be making sure that you are meeting the exceptionally high standards of copy for this company. As part of a team of six, you will be meeting tight deadlines on a daily basis and ensuring regular flow of articles onto the website. Must have a keen eye for detail and confidence in working with challenging copy. Experience in subediting, and a practical knowledge of publishing law are required.

V. Casual trainer---Medilife --- Sydney,NSW Australia

Medilife requires able, reliable trainers who can demonstrate the qualities of flexibility and loyalty and join their young, fun-living team. Successful applicants will receive excellent hourly rates. Suitable training provided to the right applicant.

1. Which of the following are specially required to most of the positions in the ads?

A. Experience and responsibilities        B. Experience and good English.

C. Special skills and English                        D. Responsibilities and bachelor’s degree

2. The positions are offered in _____ different countries.

A. three                B. four               C. five               D. six

3. Which position is possible for a fresh university graduate to apply to?

A. Education director  B. Associate product manager C. Casual trainer D. Export manager.

4. From Passage IV we can infer that a subeditor’s work is to _____.

A. write articles for website                B. copy information from the Internet

C. enforce publishing laws                 D. examine other people’s writing