问题 单项选择题

在美国商界,有很多人反对政府对商业的干预。他们认为,这种=F预提高了商业成本,削弱了有益的竞争,最终对企业和公众都不利。他们列举了货车运输业、航空业和电讯业这样一些行业,在这些行业中非干预政策带来了明显的经济效益。但这些人所持的观点忽略了诸如金融业这样一些行业,政府干预在这些行业中是至关重要的。事实上在30年代,如果没有政府的干预,这个行业中某些部分会彻底崩溃。 以下哪项,最为恰当地指出了题干所使用的方法

A.通过反例来驳斥对方的观点。

B.指出对方的观点中存在着前后矛盾。

C.对对方立论的动机提出疑问。

D.对对方论据的真实性提出质疑。

E.指出对方在论证中运用的是不正确的推理。

答案

参考答案:A

解析:题干中美国商界很多人通过列举货车运输业、航空业和电信业等行业,归纳出一般性的结论:政府干预商业是不应该的。但题干作者则举出金融业这个反例来进行反驳,即在金融行业中政府干预是至关重要的。题干的论证属于用一个反例来驳倒对方的一般性论断的直接反驳方法。相当于中国古代逻辑著作《墨经》所说的一种重要的反驳方式“止”(即使得对方停止的意思)。《墨经》说:“彼以其然者,以为此其然也,则举不然者而间之。”即对方通过列举正面事例,就得出一个全称结论,这时我就用一个反面事例来驳难。

单项选择题 B型题
单项选择题

Passage Four

Before the summer of 2000, the 54 year old John Haughom could accomplish just about any thing at work. "I could move mountains if I put my mind to it."he says of those days. But that summer Haughom found he couldn’t move them any more. On the phone with his wife one morn ing, Haughom broke down. A couple of days later Haughom checked himself in for a three-week stay at the Professional Renewal Center, an in-patient clinic 30 miles outside Kansas City that helps him deal with stress.
Haughom is far from alone. A host of new studies and plenty of anecdotal evidence show that stress in the workplace is skyrocketing. Whatever the cause, stress levels are at record highs. The statistics are startling. According to a new study by the federal government’s Nation al Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, more than half the working people in the U.S. view job stress as a major problem in their lives. This year the European Community officially dubbed stress the second-biggest occupational-health problem facing the continent.
Ten years ago experts warned that stress was out of control, in part because of a shaky economy. What’s notable about today’s wave of stressed-out workers is that it rises all the way to the top. Lack of control is generally considered one of the biggest job stressors, so it used to be thought that middle managers carried the brunt: sandwiched between the top and the bottom, they end up with little authority. Powerful chief executive officers (CEOs) were seen as the least threatened by stress. But in today’s tough economy, top executives don’t have as much control as they used to. "Stress is just part of the job, fortunately or unfortunately, stress’is part of our character building," Lebenthal says. "But I think I don’t need any more character building. What I need is a vacation."
But if you think that going on vacation is hard—and studies show that 85%of corporate executives don’t use all the time off they’re entitled to. Being able to handle stress is perhaps the most basic of job expectations. So among the corporate elite, succumbing to it is considered a shameful weakness. Stress has become the last affliction that people won’t dare admit to. Most senior executives who are undergoing treatment for stress—and even many who aren’t—refused to talk on the record about the topic."Nothing good can come out of having your name in a story like this," one CEO said through his therapist.

What is the European Community’s attitude toward stress

A.Stress is a disease that people should try to handle.

B.Stress has great influence on working people’s lives.

C.Stress is one of the most serious occupational diseases.

D.Stress is a major problem all the people face.