问题 问答题 案例分析题

案例中润食品股份有限公司审计程序的质疑及改进【案例背景】中润食品股份有限公司(以下简称中润食品)是一家集饲养、屠宰、深加工、销售为一体的农业产业化龙头企业。中润食品现有水润、冰润、华润三大品牌八大系列共1000多个品种在全国300多个大中小城市销售,中润食品享有自营出口权。中润食品先后通过了ISO9000质量认证,OC质量认证,HACC认证,同时,冰润品牌荣获“中国名牌”荣誉称号及质量免检产品证书,其中罐头、火腿系列产品,远销欧美等国家。中润食品的收入确认政策为:对于国内销售,在将产品交付客户并取得客户签字的收货确认单时确认收入;对于出口销售,在相关产品装船或装机并取得装船单、装机单时确认收入。中润食品于2014年3月1日聘请哲海会计师事务所审计其2014年度财务报表,哲海会计师事务所委派注册会计师杨冰为审计项目合伙人。杨冰在复核部分审计项目组成员的工作底稿时,注意到以下事项:(1)在实施存货监盘时,存货监盘计划要求,在对存货盘点结果进行测试时,采取从存货盘点记录中选取项目追查至存货实物的方法。在抽盘过程中,审计项目组成员李雪发现1个样本项目存在盘点错误,要求中润食品在盘点记录中更正该项错误。李雪认为该错误在数量和金额方面均不重要,因此,得出抽盘结果满意的结论,不再实施其他审计程序。(2)审计项目组成员周鑫在对银行存款进行审计时,对于基本存款账户采用积极式函证的方式,对于期末金额较小的一般账户采用消极式函证的方式,对于期末金额为零的账户主要采用检查相关记录和原始凭证验证其余额。函证内容为中润食品在银行的存款金额。在实施函证时,周鑫将询证函交由中润食品的出纳员填写银行账号、存款金额等事项后,由周鑫审核后交由出纳送交银行,回函寄送中润食品后由出纳交由周鑫。(3)对于国内销售,中润食品的物流部门在将产成品发运至客户后,会计信息系统将自动生成发运凭证。审计项目组成员张辉在实施销售收入截止测试时,将销售收入的入账日期与产成品的发运凭证日期进行了核对,未发现异常。(4)在对应收账款实施函证时,对于应收安玛特卖场(系境外客户)的询证函未收到回函,应收安玛特卖场的金额为1180万美元,审计项目组成员王娜执行替代审计程序,从应收账款借方发生额选取样本,检查相关的销售合同、销售发票、出库单以及相关记账凭证,并确认这些文件中的记录是一致的,针对上述检查,未发现异常,因此不需要实施进一步的审计程序。对于应收华明公司的款项,询证函回函金额与中润食品账面金额存在860万元的差异,经询问中润食品财务经理得知,回函差异是由于华明公司的回函金额已扣除其在2014年12月31日以电汇的方式向中润食品支付的一笔860万元的货款。中润食品于2015年1月10日实际收到该笔款项,并记入2015年应收账款明细账中,该回函差异不构成错报,无须实施进一步的审计程序。(5)中润食品有一项利率互换合约,其公允价值由财务部人员自行计算取得。由于审计项目组成员石慧缺乏审核该利率互换合约公允价值的能力,未对该公允价值计算过程进行详细检查。【案例要求】根据上述事项,逐项指出杨冰在复核项目组成员的工作底稿时,应该提出哪些质疑和改进建议。

答案

参考答案:

1.事项(1):(1)对于采取从存货盘点记录中选取项目追查至存货实物的方法不当。改进建议:还应从存货实物中选取项目追查至盘点记录,以证实存货记录完整性。(2)在抽盘中发现盘点错误,项目组成员李雪认为该错误在数量和金额方面均不重要,不再实施其他审计程序的做法不当。改进建议:抽盘过程中发现的错误很可能意味着中润食品的盘点中还存在其他错误。应当查明原因,并考虑潜在错误的范围和重大程度。2.事项(2):(1)函证方式不正确;改进建议:所有银行函证均应采用积极式函证方式。(2)在实施函证时,没有对函证实施过程进行严格的控制。改进建议:应由注册会计师控制询证函的发送和回收。(3)函证对象不正确。改进建议:应当对所有的账户函证。(4)函证内容不正确。改进建议:不应当仅仅函证存款,还应当包括借款、担保等事项。3.事项(3):根据发运凭证的日期进行销售测试不正确。改进建议:应当根据取得的客户签字的收货确认单的日期进行销售截止测试。4.事项(4):(1)中润食品对于出口销售收入的确认时点为相关产品装船或装机并取得装船单或装机单时,但是执行的替代程序并没有检查装船单或装机单。改进建议:注册会计师还应进一步检查装船单或装机单。如果装船单或装机单时间确系2015年,王娜应提出审计调整,建议中润食品冲回相关应收账款和销售收入。(2)王娜只是取得中润食品财务经理的口头解释,未对被审计单位资产负债表后是否真实收到860万元货款进行追查。改进建议:应结合货币资金审计,检查2015年1月10日实际收到该笔860万元货款的银行进账单,确认被审计单位在资产负债表日后是否实际收到客户华明公司的860万元货款。5.事项(5):未对该公允价值计算过程进行详细检查不正确。改进建议:应当由具有专业胜任能力的项目组成员,对互换合约公允价值的计算过程进行重薪测算,如果项目组成员均无法胜任对公允价值估值的审核,需要利用专家的工作。

阅读理解

.

Hoorah!I have escaped the Czech (捷克) Republic! I am now wearing light clothing and sunglasses, although the latter are superfluous today, as it is cool and overcast with cloud and it has rained slightly.

The city of Qatar (卡塔尔) is flat and sandy with few trees — mostly palms. You can see construction everywhere, new streets with hotels and apartment blocks in Venice theme. It’s a mix of super modern and traditional building styles. Everything looks new including the vehicles. There are many huge roundabouts; no traffic rules or at least no one obeys any. The huge 4-storey shopping mall in fantastic style has an ice rink (溜冰场) on the ground floor. Thousands of people walk round the waterfront after dark.

Qataris are very religious and there are calls to prayers regularly. Qatari men are dressed in all sorts of traditional clothing plus western dresses. You can easily find imported labour from South Asian countries, poorly paid and discriminated against. I am told that Qataris don’t hide their racist attitudes.

Women are always wonderful sights. Some are in all sorts of black clothing with face uncovered; some totally enveloped; lots wearing western dresses. Best sight so far: a woman in a mall completely wrapped in black including gloves, not even an eye shown — wearing glasses on the outside of her veil (面纱), using a cell phone while fingering a dress.

I am living with my employers — a New Zealand couple, and another teacher named Wayne, all about my age. We share one apartment. I have a large room with a bathroom attached: it is a little run-down but very comfortable. The only rather annoying thing is that I have to use the laptop on my bed as there is no desk and chair in here. As soon as it is clear that I will be staying I will make a change to all this. I haven’t lived with other people for many years and have been used to living alone so it will be interesting to see how this works.

49. The best title for this passage is ________.

A. The New Life with My Employers               B. General Observation of Qataris

C. My Adventure in the Czech Republic           D. My First Impressions of Qatar

50. The underlined part in paragraph one can be explained as ________.

A. it will be a fine day later                B. light clothing is helpless with cold

C. sunglasses appear fantastic            D. sunglasses become unnecessary

51. In the author’s eyes, Qatar is a ________.

A. rich western industrialized country            B. backward agricultural country

C. modern society with religious tradition     D. nation closed to the outside world

52. It is true that the author is ________.                 

A. pleased with her present living condition   B. missing her days in the Czech Republic

C. not certain how long she will be staying     D. worried about her relation with her boss

单项选择题